Home > Insurance Blog > The Biggest Medicare Advantage Disadvantages

The Biggest Medicare Advantage Disadvantages

That Could Cost You Thousands

Medicare Advantage plans have experienced a significant surge in popularity. Enrollment has increased significantly from 39% to 54% of Medicare-eligible people in 2024, a dramatic rise over the last five years. These plans look attractive at first with their bundled benefits and extra perks, but Medicare Advantage plans’ disadvantages could cost you thousands in unexpected expenses.

The plans offer vision, hearing, and dental benefits that original Medicare doesn’t cover, but they come with severe drawbacks. Plans required approximately 50 million prior authorization requests in 2023—roughly two for every person enrolled—and 3.2 million of these requests faced full or partial denials. Taxpayers spend 22% more per Medicare Advantage enrollee compared to the cost of traditional Medicare. Your budget faces an even greater risk, as these plans can set an out-of-pocket maximum as high as $9,350 in 2025.

Let’s get into why Medicare Advantage plans often fall short of expectations. We’ll explore the pitfalls to watch for and help you determine if these increasingly problematic plans fit your healthcare needs.

Why Medicare Advantage Seems Like a Good Deal

People looking at Medicare coverage often feel drawn to Medicare Advantage plans. Private insurance companies offer these plans as an attractive package that appears to address all healthcare concerns. Let’s examine what makes these plans appear so attractive at first.

Bundled benefits and low premiums

Medicare Advantage’s “bundled” approach provides an all-in-one solution that simplifies healthcare decisions. These plans typically include Medicare Part A (hospital), Part B (medical), and Part D (prescription drugs) in one package ^[1]. You won’t need to deal with multiple plans and payments.

The price tag catches the attention of seniors watching their budget. In 2024, all but one of these enrollees in individual Medicare Advantage plans with prescription drug coverage pay nothing beyond the standard Medicare Part B premium ^[2]. This zero-dollar monthly premium appeals to people living on fixed incomes ^[3].

Medicare Advantage plans also set yearly limits on out-of-pocket costs for Part A and B covered services—something Original Medicare doesn’t do ^[1]. You pay nothing for covered services after reaching this limit for the rest of the year. Many people find this predictability reassuring.

Extra perks like dental and vision

Original Medicare has significant coverage gaps, especially in dental services. Medicare typically doesn’t cover routine dental services, such as cleanings, fillings, or dentures, in most cases ^[4]. Seniors must pay out-of-pocket or buy separate coverage.

Medicare Advantage plans are a great way to get these extra benefits. The seven largest firms handle 83% of all enrollees with near-universal enrollment in plans that offer vision (99%), hearing (98%), fitness (98%), and dental (96%) benefits ^[1]. These extras help address essential health needs that require separate insurance or direct payment.

Many plans provide over-the-counter benefits (84%), remote access technologies (72%), and meal benefits (71%) ^[1]. Some plans even include transportation services, bathroom safety devices, and caregiver support, though these aren’t as common ^[1].

The appeal of coordinated care

The most significant advantage stems from the coordinated care in these plans. Medicare Advantage works through provider networks that help your doctors share information about your health effectively ^[5]. Your care improves because tests aren’t repeated, medical errors decrease, and providers share information.

This approach brings tangible benefits:

Care that focuses on your specific needs
Providers who access the same test results and treatments
Fewer medical errors and drug interactions
Less time spent repeating tests and appointments ^[5]

The simplified healthcare experience under one umbrella appeals to many people. You won’t need to handle multiple relationships with different providers and insurance companies.

Medicare Advantage enrollment has more than doubled in the last 15 years, approaching half of the total Medicare population ^[1]. However, these attractive features often come with significant tradeoffs that can cost thousands in the long run.

The Reality of Limited Provider Networks

The Reality of Limited Medicare Advantage Plan Provider Networks

_{Image Source:}_{The Incidental Economist}

A significant drawback of Medicare Advantage plans hides behind their attractive bundled benefits: limited provider networks. Original Medicare lets you see almost any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare nationwide. Medicare Advantage plans restrict your choices to providers within their network.

How HMO and PPO plans restrict access

Your access restrictions depend on whether you choose an HMO (Health Maintenance Organization) or PPO (Preferred Provider Organization) plan. These plans work quite differently:

HMO plans have stricter rules. You must receive all your care from in-network providers, except in emergencies or for urgent care [6]. Most HMOs require you to pick a primary care physician (PCP). This doctor coordinates your care and refers you to specialists [7]. The biggest risk? Your plan might not cover any out-of-network care, leaving you to pay the whole bill ^[8].

PPO plans give you more choices. They let you see out-of-network providers who accept Medicare, but you’ll pay more ^[7]. Despite this, PPO members pay significantly more for care outside their network ^[8].

These network limits raise serious concerns. Medicare Advantage networks include all but one of these physicians in a county on average ^[9]. The situation appears worse because 35% of Medicare Advantage members are enrolled in “narrow-network” plans [9]. Access to specialists can be minimal. These plans include only 23% of psychiatrists in a county on average. Approximately 36% of plans collaborate with fewer than 10% of local psychiatrists ^[9].

The problem grows as more healthcare systems across the country stop accepting Medicare Advantage insurance contracts ^[10]. HealthPartners, one of the largest hospital and clinic operators in the Twin Cities, recently left UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage networks due to high denial rates ^[10].

What to do if your provider isn’t in-network

You’ll need to act fast if you find your provider has left your plan’s network. Select a new in-network provider promptly to maintain your coverage [6]. Your plan should notify you at least 30 days in advance of your provider leaving the network ^[6]. You should still check your provider’s network status before appointments.

A helpful but rarely used protection exists. Your Medicare Advantage plan must arrange out-of-network services at in-network rates if you need covered care that’s not available in their network ^[2]. This rule applies to both HMO and PPO plans ^[2].

The annual Medicare Open Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7. During this time, check if your preferred providers participate in plans you’re considering ^[6]. Medicare’s Care Compare tool helps you search for providers ^[3]. However, these directories aren’t always accurate. A Government Accountability Office study found that CMS doesn’t properly verify provider information from MA plans ^[11].

Limited access to your preferred doctors stands as one of Medicare Advantage plans’ most significant drawbacks. This can disrupt your care, increase costs, and limit your options for specialized treatment.

The Burden of Prior Authorization and Denials

“Treatments and hospital stays might need prior approval, which can delay necessary or life-saving care.” — Quote.com Editorial Team, Insurance and financial product comparison platform

Medicare Advantage plans face another significant obstacle, in addition to restricted networks: prior authorization requirements. Your healthcare provider must get approval before providing certain services. These barriers can impact your care and take a significant toll on your wallet.

How prior authorization delays care

Prior authorization requests have increased significantly, with over 50 million submitted to Medicare Advantage plans in 2023—approximately 1.8 requests per enrollee [12]. These rules cause significant delays. Approximately 22% of Medicare Advantage enrollees report that their care was delayed due to insurance approvals. Traditional Medicare users face fewer delays, with only 13% reporting similar issues ^[13].

The effects extend far beyond mere inconvenience. A 2023 physician survey revealed that 94% of doctors reported prior authorization delayed their patients’ necessary care ^[14]. Even worse, 24% of physicians reported that prior authorization caused serious health problems for patients ^[15]. These included:

Patient hospitalization (19%)
Life-threatening situations that needed immediate action (13%)
Permanent bodily damage, disability, or death (7%)

Patients often face difficult choices: wait it out, pay out of pocket, or forgo needed care ^[14].

The role of AI in denying services

Medicare Advantage plans now utilize AI and predictive algorithms to determine when to stop covering treatments ^[1]. This trend raises concerns because these AI systems work like “black boxes.” Insurance companies often refuse to explain how they make their decisions.

“They say, ‘That’s proprietary,'” says Amanda Ford, who aids rehabilitation services for patients. “It’s always that canned response: ‘The patient can be managed in a lower level of care'” ^[1].

A Senate investigation revealed that UnitedHealthcare, Humana, and CVS rely heavily on automation and AI to review prior authorization requests. This matches up with their sharply rising denial rates ^[16]. UnitedHealthcare and CVS denied post-acute care three times more often than their overall denial rates in 2022. Humana’s denial rate soared even higher, 16 times above normal ^[17].

What happens when rehab is denied

Denial of rehabilitation and skilled nursing services can be particularly devastating for patients. Medicare Advantage patients who get denied continued rehab face tough choices: pay thousands out of pocket, return home without needed care, or battle through a lengthy appeals process ^[1].

The numbers tell a troubling story, but few people take a stand. Only 11.7% of care denials saw appeals in 2023 ^[14]. The good news? Those who appealed won big – almost 82% got decisions in their favor ^[14].

This high success rate in appeals raises red flags about these denials. Are they based on medical needs or just ways to save money? One healthcare advocate puts it bluntly: “They’re hoping that their endurance is greater than ours” ^[1]—betting that patients and providers will give up instead of fighting denials.

Unexpected Costs That Add Up Quickly

“If you need expensive medical care, you could end up paying a large amount out of pocket, even with the annual cap on your share of the bills.” — ValuePenguin Editorial Team, Healthcare research and analysis publication

Medicare Advantage plans conceal a financial reality that often catches many people off guard when they begin using their benefits. What appears to be a way to save money at first can end up costing you a lot more than you expected.

Copays for every visit

Original Medicare, combined with a Medigap plan, covers most out-of-pocket costs. Medicare Advantage plans work differently – they need you to pay copayments for almost every service. You’ll pay $25 for each primary care visit or $40 for visits with specialists ^[18]. These small payments add up faster than you’d think, especially if you have ongoing health conditions.

Your hospital stays can take a significant toll on your wallet. Daily copays might cost you hundreds of dollars ^[4]. The plan also charges you for lab work, x-rays, ambulance rides, and emergency room visits ^[4]. You’ll pay 20% of the cost for diagnostic imaging, chemotherapy, radiation, and dialysis – just like Original Medicare, but you won’t have Medigap’s safety net ^[4].

Drug coverage gaps and formulary issues

Medicare Advantage plans typically cover prescription drugs, but costs vary widely based on their formulary—the list of covered medications. These plans categorize drugs into tiers, which determine your payment amount ^[18]. Lower-tier generic drugs often cost less, but brand-name or specialty drugs in higher tiers can drain your savings ^[18].

The formulary changes each year. A drug that’s cheap this year might cost you a lot more next year ^[18]. Starting January 1, 2025, Part D coverage has three phases: a deductible phase, an initial coverage period, and a catastrophic coverage phase [19]. Good news, though – after you spend $2,000 on drugs, you pay nothing for covered medications for the rest of the year ^[20].

Why out-of-network care can be expensive

Going outside your plan’s network can hurt your wallet. HMO members typically pay all costs for out-of-network care, except in emergencies [21]. PPO plans offer more choices but charge significantly more for out-of-network services ^[21].

The out-of-pocket limit for Medicare Advantage plans is expected to reach $8,850 in 2024 for in-network services and $13,300 for both in-network and out-of-network services ^[21]. If your specialist isn’t in the network, you face a tough choice: find a new doctor or pay the full cost yourself ^[22].

When You Want Out—But Can’t Get Medigap

People often discover the actual cost of Medicare Advantage only after they attempt to leave these plans. Many feel stuck because they have few options to switch back to Original Medicare with supplemental coverage.

Why switching back is more complicated than it seems.

The biggest problem with leaving Medicare Advantage is simple. Your guaranteed right to buy Medigap insurance usually runs out after you’ve been in a Medicare Advantage plan for more than 12 months. Therefore, insurance companies can decline your Medigap coverage request or charge significantly higher premiums based on your health.

Most states let Medigap insurers use medical underwriting after your original enrollment period ends. This means they can review your health history, decline your application, or charge more if you have pre-existing conditions. All but one of these states (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and New York) require Medigap insurers to offer at least some policies to all Medicare beneficiaries, regardless of their health status.

How Medigap eligibility changes over time

You have guaranteed Medigap rights during specific times:

Your Initial Enrollment Period at the time you become eligible for Medicare Part B
The 12-month trial period after you first join Medicare Advantage
After certain qualifying events, like moving away from your plan’s service area

Getting Medigap coverage becomes harder as these periods end, especially as you get older and develop health issues. What looks like a choice you can change at 65 might become permanent by the time you’re 75 or 80.

What to consider before enrolling in an MA

These restrictions mean you should review several factors before choosing Medicare Advantage:

Long-term health outlook: Think about future health needs, not just today’s
Regional provider acceptance: Check if specialists near you take Medicare Advantage plans
Financial stability: Make sure you can handle potential out-of-pocket costs up to the maximum limit

Remember that while you can switch Medicare Advantage plans each year easily enough, going back to Original Medicare with affordable supplemental coverage might be impossible. This depends on your health status and your location.

Conclusion

Medicare Advantage plans appear attractive at first glance, offering zero-dollar premiums and bundled benefits. However, our in-depth analysis in this piece reveals that these plans have drawbacks that could result in thousands of dollars in unexpected expenses.

The restricted provider networks significantly reduce your healthcare choices. You’ll often find that less than half of the local physicians in your area are covered. This becomes a real problem when you need a specialist or your doctors leave the network. The prior authorization requirements also create significant hurdles, with nearly 50 million requests submitted in 2023 alone. These requirements often delay the treatments you need.

The financial reality of Medicare Advantage is different from what the marketing suggests. You might see those low or zero-dollar premiums, but you’ll still pay copays for almost everything. Drug coverage has its limits, and your out-of-pocket costs could reach $8,850 for in-network care or $13,300 for out-of-network services. These costs pile up fast, especially if you have chronic conditions.

Making a switch back to Original Medicare with supplemental coverage becomes more challenging over time. Insurance companies can deny you coverage or charge much higher premiums based on your health unless you live in one of the few states with guaranteed Medigap access.

Consider your long-term healthcare needs, doctor priorities, and financial situation before enrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan. These plans work well for some people, especially those in good health and areas with robust provider networks, but they can become pricey and limiting for others. Note that your simple choice at 65 could significantly impact your healthcare options and finances for years to come.

Your best Medicare choice depends on your specific situation. Living in Florida, Illinois, Nevada, or anywhere else, research your options thoroughly. An independent insurance advisor can help explain what works best in your area. Making the right Medicare decision requires balancing your current budget with long-term healthcare security.

Key Takeaways

While Medicare Advantage plans attract enrollees with zero-dollar premiums and bundled benefits, they come with hidden costs and restrictions that could significantly impact your healthcare and finances.

• Limited networks restrict your choices: Medicare Advantage plans include less than half of physicians in most counties, potentially forcing you to switch doctors or pay full costs out-of-network.

• Prior authorization creates dangerous delays: With 50 million requests in 2023 and AI-driven denials increasing, necessary treatments are frequently delayed or denied, sometimes causing serious health consequences.

• Hidden costs accumulate rapidly: Despite low premiums, copays for every visit, drug coverage gaps, and out-of-pocket maximums up to $8,850 can create substantial unexpected expenses.

• Switching back becomes nearly impossible: Once enrolled beyond 12 months, returning to Original Medicare with Medigap coverage requires medical underwriting in most states, potentially leaving you trapped in Medicare Advantage.

• Consider long-term implications before enrolling: What seems like a reversible decision at 65 may become permanent as you age and develop health conditions, making careful evaluation of your future healthcare needs essential.

The key is understanding that Medicare Advantage’s attractive upfront benefits often come with significant long-term tradeoffs that could cost you thousands in restricted access, delayed care, and unexpected expenses.

FAQs

Q1. What is the most significant drawback of Medicare Advantage plans? The most significant drawback is often the limited provider networks. Medicare Advantage plans typically include fewer than half of the physicians in a county, which can restrict your healthcare choices and potentially force you to switch doctors or pay full costs for out-of-network care.

Q2. Why are some beneficiaries choosing to leave their Medicare Advantage plans? Many beneficiaries are leaving due to difficulties in accessing needed care, dissatisfaction with the cost of care, and concerns about the quality of care provided. Some find that the reality of these plans doesn’t match their initial expectations.

Q3. What concerns do healthcare providers have about Medicare Advantage plans? Healthcare providers often express frustration with the extensive prior authorization requirements and high denial rates associated with Medicare Advantage plans. These issues can lead to treatment delays and increased administrative burdens for medical practices.

Q4. Are there hidden costs associated with Medicare Advantage plans? Yes, there can be unexpected costs. Despite low or zero-dollar premiums, enrollees often face copays for most services, potential gaps in drug coverage, and out-of-pocket maximums that can reach up to $8,850 for in-network care or $13,300 for out-of-network services.

Q5. How difficult is it to switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare with supplemental coverage? Switching back can be challenging, especially if you have been enrolled in Medicare Advantage for more than 12 months. In most states, insurance companies can deny you Medigap coverage or charge higher premiums based on your health status, potentially leaving you with limited options.

References

Get A Quote

Customer Reviews

5 stars!

Shell B

Excellent customer service and very friendly and helpful 😃

Pamela H

They made selecting the right healthcare plan a smooth process.

Donald W